You’ll often see these two words in the same paragraph or even the same sentence, and at first glance, it seems natural that healthy and nutritional would go hand-in-hand. But, a closer examination reveals the true scope of each word, and a better understanding may help you make better food choices. (No judgment. Some of us are still holding on to our love of a certain breakfast cereal with little, multi-colored marshmallows that are “magically delicious.”)
What do healthy and nutritional mean?
First, let’s look at our own definitions of the terms. We define the word healthy as “pertaining to or characteristic of good health.” The word healthy was first recorded in 1545–55.
The word nutritional is defined as “the act or process of nourishing or of being nourished.” The word nutrition first originated in 1375–1425 from late Middle English, and it’s from the Latin word But, what’s nourish? It’s what is necessary for life, health, and growth.
So, nutritional and nourish are what foods provide to us in the way of vitamins, minerals, and sustenance. And, interestingly enough nutrition came before healthy, but did nutrition influence the meaning of healthy?
Does good nutrition equal good health?
When we say health, we are pretty much referring to our bodies, the machines that run hard every day and that need maintenance and care.
When we say nutrition, we’re generally talking about the right kind of fuel to make our human-body machines run. Simple enough. It seems that good nutrition does equal good health then.
How are nutritional and healthy different?
Is sugary, marshmallow cereal nutritional? Yes. Is it healthy? That may be where we begin to see the divide.
If the word healthy means something that is conducive to good health, it seems wrong to label sugary cereals as nutritional and definitely inaccurate to label them as healthy. They’re clearly the bad kind of nutritious and not healthy for us.
But, what about superfoods? Is this just a way of rebranding some pretty humble foods like blueberries, walnuts, salmon, and sweet potatoes to boost sales. Maybe. But, that doesn’t mean it’s a bad thing. These foods used to be staples of the American diet but have fallen out of popularity over the years with the rise of processed and fast foods. However, with the new superfood status, the popularity of truly nutritional foods is on the rise again. These foods deserve the healthy and nutritional labels.
What happens when we drown kale in brown sugar (and sesame, yum) though? Is it still a nutritional and healthy food? The kale may not lose its nutritional value, if cooked properly, but the healthy aspect is now jeopardized by the addition of sugar. Most nutritionists agree that sugar is a fairly evil force in the food world that can taint the most healthy superfood. And, eating kale drowned in brown sugar may not be as bad for you as those sugary marshmallows, but it’s definitely not considered healthy anymore either.
Similarly, acai berry is a superfood, but it loses it high nutritional value when it’s turned into juice with high levels of added sugar. Green tea has very high levels of antioxidants, but falls on the wrong side of healthy when its processed with less healthy teas and served with sugar. Some whole grains are processed to a degree where they also lose their nutritional value or even cause the body to process them in a way that spikes sugar levels.
So, perhaps the best thing to remember when shopping for (good) nutritional and healthy food is that you can take a perfectly nutritious food and turn it into something that has a less positive, or healthy, effect on your body. If you process it in a certain way, overcook it, or add enough sugar (or cute little marshmallows), it won’t be healthy at all.
What does nutritional labeling tell us?
Sometimes, in a moment of utter hunger, we may look at the label of a pre-packaged snack food and see that it’s under 200 calories with only a few grams of fat. Yes, it has a bunch of sodium and added sugar (how much is too much?), and a bunch of other things we’re not sure about. But, it seems slightly healthy (and it says “low fat” in a green banner), so down the hatch it goes.
The way your body breaks down that processed food—and its list of mystery ingredients—is quite different from the way your body would process, say, an apple and a handful of nuts. These are “whole foods” (see where that supermarket chain got the name?), which are always more healthy and nutritional than anything processed and pre-packaged. Your body breaks down whole foods slowly throughout the day, making all those nutrients do their job, giving you more energy, and keeping you full and fueled.
Nutritional labeling is important, and an important part of it is the ingredients list. The fewer the ingredients (and the fewer mystery ingredients) the better. The ingredients list for a crisp, juicy apple is: apple. That’s the best kind of list.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has good information on their web site about reading these labels. They advise that the most important things are the serving size (beware that some packages are considered two servings, when you might think of it as one), the nutrition info (fiber, sugar, salt, fat, etc.), and the percentage of “daily value” (you want a high daily value of the nutrients that are good for you, like calcium, and a low daily value of the nutrients that aren’t so good, such as saturated fat).
The power of words
That said, even the FDA revises its standards frequently for what it deems “healthy foods,” as they did recently to consider “added” sugars vs. “naturally occurring” sugars. Now, all sugars are not equal.
The science of nutrition is a fluid one and keeping up takes some work. Understanding the nomenclature is helpful, as is knowing that healthy is a state of being, and that good nutrition is what gets you there. But, beware of catchy marketing and claims to be part of a “balanced” meal, because without the nutritional info to back it up, those claims are just food clickbait.
Want to learn some other words that get tacked onto our food by crafty marketers? Check out our Buzzwords That Are Tasty Enough To Eat.