Where does Would you rather come from?
In the 1960s, Would you rather appears in psychological studies of motivation as a stock question asking a respondent to pick between two, fixed options. Evidence for the Would you rather game as such comes in the 1970s, used in a study of aggressive behavior in children. By the 2000s, Would you rather was well-established as a conversational or party game, with various popular books compiling different Would you rather questions for adults and children to play alike.
To play the game, a person has to address a dilemma, usually between two very appealing, unpleasant, or otherwise tricky choices:
- Would you rather have the ability to fly like an eagle or swim like a whale?
- Would you rather win the lottery and never have to work again or have your dream job and work until you're 80?
- Would you rather eat a spider or drink rotten milk?
Then, participants have to say which they would rather (or "prefer") do and why. Choosing both or neither is discouraged—the point is that participants are forced to pick one, resulting in humorous or engaging discussion about why.
Would you rather was developed into a formal board game in the early 2000s, with subsequent editions. In the 2000–10s, the TV cartoon Family Guy regularly featured characters playing the game, often as as vehicle for outrageous scenarios (e.g., Would you rather be a hobo with a 5% chance of getting inherited by a rich guy or be Hitler two years before the end of WWII)?
In 2011, Irish comedian Graham Norton hosted a TV show based on the game for BBC America, called Would You Rather...? with Graham Norton, with celebrity panelists comically competing for points by answering would you rather questions. Would you rather became a popular meme on social media after the launch of the app Either in 2012, which allows users to poll people on their preferences and displays their results in an eye-catching way. Screenshots of the results of the app's would you rather questions circulated on Reddit and other social-media platforms in early 2013.
In March, 2018, social-media platform Snapchat caused outcry for running an ad for a game it called Would You Rather, asking people if they would rather slap Rihanna or punch Chris Brown, a troubling joke about Brown's domestic violence against Rihanna. Snapchat quickly took down the ad.
Who uses Would you rather?
Who would you rather listen to? J. Cole or Jigglypuff?
@SimoneAlexa, April, 2018
Would you rather eat a Pocky stick that's 8 feet long OR one that's as fat as a hot dog?
@RoosterTeeth, April, 2018
Would you rather love the more, and suffer the more, or love the less, and suffer the less?
Julian Barnes, The Only Story, 2018