Dictionary.com
Thesaurus.com

cigarillo vs. cigar

[sig-uh-ril-oh] / ˌsɪg əˈrɪl oʊ /

noun

plural

cigarillos
  1. a small, thin cigar.

  2. a cigarette with a wrapping of tobacco instead of paper.

[si-gahr] / sɪˈgɑr /

noun

  1. a more or less cylindrical roll of tobacco cured for smoking, of any of various lengths, thicknesses, degrees of straightness, etc., usually wrapped in a tobacco leaf.

idioms

  1. no cigar, not being a winning or successful effort, as if not good enough to earn a cigar as a prize.

    He made a good try at fielding the ball, but no cigar.