Examples of Bechdel test
Examples of Bechdel test
Where does Bechdel test come from?
The Bechdel test aims to bring attention to and address gender inequality in media. It was created in 1985 by its namesake, cartoonist Alison Bechdel, and her friend Liz Wallace, hence it sometimes is called the Bechdel-Wallace test.
The principle first appeared in a 1985 strip in Bechdel’s comic Dykes To Watch Out For, which establishes its three-part rule:
- The work needs to feature two female characters
- who talk to each other
- about something other than a man.
The principle was popularly referred to as the Bechdel test by 2007, around which it was receiving more mainstream coverage, such as in media critic Anita Sarkeesian’s popular YouTube video explaining the concept in 2009.
The website bechdeltest.com, which maintains a database of movies that pass or fail it, went live in 2013. Their statistics show that just under 58% of movies meet all three criteria of the Bechdel test. This indicates just how many films (notably, Pacific Rim in 2013) fail to represent women.
Increasingly nuanced discussions of the Bechdel test emerged in the late 2010s. A 2016 Guardian article took some issue with the test, as a film like Gravity (2016) technically fails it but centers on one strong woman while The Twilight Saga (2008–12) passes though its female characters aren’t fully realized on their own terms.
Criticism aside, the Bechdel test remains a useful and general way to gauge the representation of women in media.
Who uses Bechdel test?
The Bechdel test is used in media and gender studies as well in more mainstream discussion of the representation of women in media.
While the test is commonly applied to films, it has also been notably applied to video games, comics, literature, and even science journalism (Finkbeiner test).
@NadiaKamil It is a video game that passes MULTIPLE DAVIN TESTS, including the Bechdel test and the "I don't shoot anyone" test.
— Davin Pavlas (@onidavin) February 24, 2014
Spinoff versions of the test have been created to measure the representation of sexuality and people of color, such as the Vito Russo test and DuVernay test, respectively.
Proud to say that aside from our inclusivity in front of & behind the camera, @onedayatatime passes the Bechdel test, Mako Mori test, Sphinx test, Vito Russo test, Sexy lamp test & DuVernay test. All take into account inclusivity in storytelling. Look 'em up! Be inspired!
— Gloria Calderón Kellett (@everythingloria) March 7, 2018
While the Bechdel test is generally seen as useful, there are still criticisms.
One is that the Bechdel test doesn’t account for quality or circumstance of the work (a film set in a monastery would not pass, for instance). It also fails to account for the lack of opportunity or participation of women in media industries that can lead to their underrepresentation or bias against them.
Solid thread, sir. My little tip: Be sure and search for diverse talent when hiring your writing team. A room with women in it is far less likely to draft a story that fails the Bechdel test; include writers of colour and you'll be rewarded with richer and more inclusive stories.
— Shaun Davis (@awkwardgeek) November 29, 2018